I agree with Freud here in the cases of people having chemical imbalances, growing up in situations that they can't help, and other events that would lead to situations of neurosis and the like. I do not agree with him in the way that, I'm assuming, all patients are responsible for their neurosis: what about a patient who ends up with a disorder because of decisions that they consciously made and they knew would lead to neurosis? I can't think of an extremely good example, but I know there are some out there. I just think their are some people out their who are responsible for the actions they make and cannot blame it on the forces in their mind.
Monday, November 10, 2008
S. Freud II
I agree with Freud here in the cases of people having chemical imbalances, growing up in situations that they can't help, and other events that would lead to situations of neurosis and the like. I do not agree with him in the way that, I'm assuming, all patients are responsible for their neurosis: what about a patient who ends up with a disorder because of decisions that they consciously made and they knew would lead to neurosis? I can't think of an extremely good example, but I know there are some out there. I just think their are some people out their who are responsible for the actions they make and cannot blame it on the forces in their mind.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment